One Judge

Read

James 4:11-12 "Brothers and sisters, do not slander one another. Anyone who speaks against a brother or sister or judges them speaks against the law and judges it. When you judge the law, you are not keeping it, but sitting in judgment on it. There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the one who is able to save and destroy. But you—who are you to judge your neighbor?"

Think

James moves from humility before God to humility before others. The connection is seamless. If you've truly humbled yourself before God, you cannot then turn around and set yourself up as judge over someone else. Slander here isn't just lying about someone. It's speaking against them. Criticizing. Deconstructing their motives. Assigning intent you can't possibly know.

Every time you speak against a brother or sister, you're not just attacking them. You're attacking the law that says to love your neighbor. You're placing yourself above the law rather than under it. When you judge the law, you stop keeping it and start presiding over it. You become a supreme court of one, deciding which parts of God's commands apply to others and which don't.

"There is only one Lawgiver and Judge." James draws the line. One. Not two. Not you and God. Just God. He alone is qualified because he alone can save and destroy. You can condemn, but you can't save. You can criticize, but you can't redeem. Judgment without the power to save is just cruelty.

"But you, who are you to judge your neighbor?" That question should silence you. Who are you? You share the same humanity. The same fallenness. The same need for grace. You stand in the same courtroom as the person you're judging, and neither of you is behind the bench. Both of you are in front of it.

Think about the last time you spoke against someone. Not to their face, necessarily. Maybe behind their back. Maybe in your own mind. You constructed a case against them. You gathered evidence. You rendered a verdict. And you did all of it without ever giving them a chance to defend themselves. That's not justice. That's a kangaroo court with a population of one.

The problem with judging others isn't that you're always wrong about what they did. Sometimes you're right. Sometimes they really did fail, really did sin, really did make a terrible choice. The problem is that being right about someone's failure doesn't qualify you to be their judge. Accuracy doesn't equal authority. You can identify the problem without being the one authorized to pass sentence.

James connects this directly to the law. When you speak against a brother or sister, you speak against the law. Why? Because the law commands love. The law says to treat others the way you want to be treated. The law says to bear one another's burdens, to be quick to listen and slow to speak, to cover a multitude of sins with love. Every act of judgment violates every one of those commands simultaneously.

And when you violate the law while claiming to enforce it, you've made yourself a hypocrite of the highest order. You're prosecuting someone for breaking the rules while breaking the rules yourself. You're holding others to a standard you're failing to meet in the very act of holding them to it.

Jesus addressed this directly in Matthew 7:1-2: "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you." The measure you use. Think about that. The standard you apply to others is the standard that will be applied to you. If you judge harshly, you'll be judged harshly. If you show no mercy in your assessment of others, no mercy will be shown in the assessment of you.

That should terrify every person who has ever looked at someone else's life and said, "I would never do that." Because the measure you just used is now the measure that applies to you. And you might be surprised how poorly you fare when your own life is held to the standard you so eagerly applied to someone else.

Consider this: the reason you judge so confidently is because you only see the outside. You see the behavior. The words. The decisions. But you don't see the struggle behind the behavior. You don't see the wound that produced the words. You don't see the pressure that led to the decision. God sees all of it. Every layer. Every motive. Every hidden factor you know nothing about. That's why he's the judge and you're not. Your information is always incomplete. Your perspective is always limited. Your empathy, no matter how developed, can never fully account for another person's internal reality. You're rendering verdicts with partial evidence, and partial evidence leads to unjust verdicts every time.

There is one Lawgiver and Judge. One. And he is the one who is able to save and destroy. You can do neither. You cannot save the person you're judging, and you have no right to destroy them. So step down. The bench was never yours to sit on.

Apply

Where have you been sitting in judgment? Over a coworker, a family member, someone at church? Today, step down from the bench. You're not the judge. You never were.

Pray

God, I have judged people I have no right to judge. I have spoken against brothers and sisters while claiming to follow the law of love. Forgive my arrogance. Remind me that there is one Lawgiver and Judge, and it is not me. Help me see people the way you see them. Not as projects for my critique. As people you love. In Jesus' name. Amen.